Sunday, March 29, 2009

Twilig-- I mean, Evermore by Alyson Noel


I find it amusing (and disappointing) that so many novels these days just seem very... similar. I am often able to describe whatever it is I'm reading by mixing multiple books together. This one, for example, is sort of a mixed up Twilight without the vampires (or werewolves for that matter) and a distinct Deadly Little Secret flavoring.

Ever, a car accident survivor, is pretty normal. Well, as long as your definition of "pretty normal" includes having the ability to hear the thoughts of those around you and frequently chatting with your 12 year old sister... who is dead. If your definition of normal does not allow for that sort of thing... well 1.) you haven't read as many fantasy/sci fi/mixes of fantasy and sci fi books as I have and 2.) you might (like Ever's high school classmates) label her "freak" instead. But not to worry, Ever does have some friends, namely an attention-seeking goth chick and the generic gay best friend. Yay for stereotypes. So, basically there's this new guy in school (I believe the word smoldering is used more than once) who everyone from the aforementioned generic gay best friend to the aforementioned goth chick seems to be falling in love with. Ever attempts to avoid him, but when she finally makes contact she (stares creepily at him for a few minutes and) notices something strange about him. He is the only person, aside from her dead sister, who lacks the ever present swirling aura that only she can see.

Even the blurb on the back of the book recalls distinct phrases from Twilight. "...she has no idea just who he really is-- or what he is. The only thing she knows is true is that she's falling deeply and helplessly in love with him." *exasperated sigh* Oh, ye gods of YA lit, I'm sure I've begged this favor of you multiple times but could I pretty please have a (fawesometastic) supernatural romance that doesn't stink of every book I've ever read in my life... okay, slight exaggeration there. But honestly, aren't any of you feeling the same way? I just want something different and amazing. Is more awesome too much to ask for?

A mediocre 4 out of 7 for a not-very-impressive novel.

Fanatically following The Logbook of the Ketty Jay,

4 comments:

Dahlia said...

Aella and Medeia, you have received the Sisterhood Award! Whoo! Stop by the link below to get it.

http://dahliaseclecticmind.blogspot.com/2009/04/sisterhood-award-and-beda.html

Reese said...

I must read this book, just so I can mock it properly.

Ree

serafina-zane said...

Ugh, I had the exact same reaction to this book. Just...so...much...meh. It was truly a struggle to finish it.
SUPERNATURAL ROMANCE LAME.
I can't summon my full cynicism though, the last supernatural-type romance I read was As You Wish, and that was pretty good, so my opinion has been skewed.

Medeia said...

Lame supernatural romances should stop existing. Right now. I haven't read a really fantastic one in... forever. I just finished The Fetch, which was also pretty good, though. Maybe they're getting better?